Review: Some Enchanted Evening (by Christina Dodd)
Some Enchanted Evening
by Christina Dodd (website)
Historical Fiction--Regency (William Morrow, 2004)
(My post about how to read my book reviews can be found here.)
Synopsis: An exiled princess, running from her past, finds a temporary home with an earl, recently returned from the Napoleonic wars. To keep her family in solvency, the princess has decided to sell face creams to the earl's family and friends. Their immediate attraction makes Clarice and Robert wary of one another, but when their pasts interfere, they are thrown together to face circumstances they never imagined.
Heat Level:
On a scale of Vanilla to Dark Chocolate, this would probably be of the more savory Milk Chocolate varieties. And the heat level builds quite nicely, from very vanilla to a deep, sugary milk chocolate. The book climaxes with a *very* long love scene (among the others), which is truly one of the most beautiful things I have ever read. All potential writers need to read this long, last love scene. A-Maze-Ing.
Eye-Roll Factor: 9/10
I think I rolled my eyes a few times at the whole "oozing masculinity" and "palpable maleness" kind of stuff. That kind of description always feels a little lazy to me. There has to be a way to explain the raw virility of an alpha male better than that. But, honestly, when that's the biggest complaint I have about the "typical romance cliche" kind of stuff, that is a *really* good sign!
The Cosmo Factor: 22/25
While I was not crazy about the way she seemed to flatter everyone around her (whether she meant it or not), I loved how intelligent and independent Clarice was in this book. She is one of the first heroines I've read in the romance genre (with the exception of Dodd's other book that I've read and loved and a few others) who actually seemed to deserve the man she ends up with. Mostly, I seem to read romances where the hero is *way* too good for the heroine (re: The Bridget Jones Syndrome), and I hate that. But in Clarice's case, I would not only invite her for a Cosmo (at night, at a bar, even) and girls' night, but I would actually sit at the table and talk to her. For the whole night, even.
The Dining Room to Bedroom Factor: 24/25
Holy Mother Lode, Batman. This guy is like the King of all Alpha Males. I could feel his alpha-ness down to my toes. And I found myself wishing I could find a genie and make Robert MacKenzie flesh and blood. Wow. The man was not only an amazing alpha, but he was intelligent and witty and loyal and fierce. And the man could fight. Holy crap. He had that kind of latent violence that is so hot about alphas in romance novels. And the love scenes! Wow. Honestly. I'm gonna read this again, just to get some of her technique. Her deep POV is excellent. :-)
The Braveheart Factor: 10/10
As far as historical accuracy, I think this was a pretty accurate story, as far as I know. I felt like the language was especially accurate. I was impressed with the way she wrote each character in the historical language, but with unique voices. It was something I'm sure other writers do, but I just happened to notice it more in this book. More importantly, there were no glaring inaccuracies.
The Nostalgia Re-Read Factor: 10/10
Oh, I'm definitely gonna read this again. No question about it. In fact, there's a good possibility I'll turn around and re-read it tomorrow! :-) Seriously, this is gonna be a keeper. And I can't wait to get to the next book in the series. I have to know what happens to these other sisters.
The Skim Factor: 10/10No skimming. The story was engaging the entire way through, the characters from whose perspective I read were all interesting enough that I never wanted to get out of their head, and I never wanted the story to end. I didn't skim at all.
The Little People Factor: 9/10
This was one of the best "little people" books I've ever read. There were four main characters I can think of who were very well-developed and whom I want to see again in future novels. I felt like the main characters interacted deeply with the minor characters, and there was enough at stake, that although I didn't go deep into the POV of the minor characters, I knew who they were and heard their voices and wanted to know more about them. Love it.
Overall Evaluation: 94/100
Wow! The highest rating I've ever given any book. That's a great sign. And honestly, I haven't been able to stop thinking about Robert MacKenzie since I stopped reading the book. I keep hoping to run into him around the corner. I doubt I will (even though I am in Canada... highest percentage of Scottish men outside of Scotland), but I would really love for that to happen. Honestly, I cannot wait to read this book again. I was so impressed with the writing... there were so many times I stopped and said out loud, "Wow, that was amazing writing right there... did you see how she did that?" It was great. She has an unfortunate tendency to overuse similies. But other than that, it is just flawless. Well-written love scenes (especially the *really* long one...), well-done characters, good action, good plotting. And sequels!! :-) Can't go wrong here.



Recent Comments